Skip to main content
Search

Assortments 8 items

Create Your Own Assortment

Create your own assortment box with your favorite Nutty flavors!
From  $21.00
+ ADD

Signature Nutty Assortment

Pre-assorted box with all of your favorite Nutty flavors! Handcrafted with Belgian chocolate and ...
From  $20.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Double Box - 23 Cups
  • Double Box - 30 Cups
$20.00
Cancel

Pre-Assorted Milk Chocolate

Our 3 best selling milk chocolate flavors in one box! Handcrafted with Belgian milk chocolate and...
From  $19.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Double Box - 23 Cups
  • Double Box - 30 Cups
  • Peanut Butter
  • Almond Butter
$19.00
Cancel

Pre-Assorted Dark Chocolate

Our 3 best selling dark chocolate flavors in one box! Handcrafted with Belgian dark chocolate (60...
From  $19.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Double Box - 23 Cups
  • Double Box - 30 Cups
  • Peanut Butter
  • Almond Butter
  • Vegan Peanut Butter
$19.00
Cancel

Create Your Own 4-Pack

Choose up to 4 flavors and put together your own pack of 4 Nutty Cups!
From  $9.50
+ ADD

Nutty 2-Packs

Grab a 2-pack of your favorite Nutty Cup flavor! 
$5.00
+ ADD
  • Original Nutty Cups
  • Dark Sea Salt Cups
  • Nutty Cookies ‘n’ Cream Cups
  • Nutty PBJ Cups
  • Nutty Pretzel Cups
  • Choco-Hazelnutty Cups
  • Nutty Almond Cups (milk)
  • Nutty Almond Cups (dark)
$5.00
Cancel

Nutty Misfits

We’re making Nutty Cups all the time… and sometimes they don’t come out perfectly. But instead of...
From  $14.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
$14.00
Cancel

Customized Cups

Customize your Nutty Cups with a special message written right on top!
If you are hoping to simpl...
From  $25.00
+ ADD

Flavors 8 items

Original Nutty Cup

Where it all began... a true classic. Smooth dark, milk or white chocolate with Jessie's freshly ...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Milk Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
  • White Chocolate
$18.00
Cancel

Cup of the Month: Nutty Brownie Caramel

We've teamed up with Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop to bring you a delectable new Nutty Cup! Inside...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$19.00
Cancel

Dark Sea Salt Cup

Belgian dark chocolate surrounds Jessie’s freshly ground nutty filling (peanut butter, almond but...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Peanut Butter
  • Almond Butter
  • Vegan Peanut Butter
$18.00
Cancel

Nutty Cookies 'n' Cream Cup

Your favorite peanut butter cup but with a Cookies 'n' Cream twist! A Belgian chocolate shell (mi...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Milk Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
$18.00
Cancel

Nutty PBJ Cup

Creamy peanut butter and Maya's Jams handmade Triple Berry Jam (based on Jessie's original recipe...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$18.00
Cancel

Nutty Pretzel Cup

Peanut butter, Belgian milk or dark chocolate and pretzel. How could you possibly go wrong?
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Milk Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
$18.00
Cancel

Nutty Almond Cup

Belgian milk or dark chocolate surrounds our creamy almond butter filling. Simply perfect!
 
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • 2-pack
  • Box of 15
  • Milk
  • Dark
$19.00
Cancel

Choco-Hazelnutty Cup

A combination of Nutella and our freshly ground peanut butter is surrounded by a Belgian chocolat...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$18.00
Cancel

Gift Card 1 item

Nutty Gift Cards


Purchasing this digital gift card creates a unique code, which the lucky recipient can enter at ...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • $5.00
  • $10.00
  • $15.00
  • $20.00
  • $25.00
  • $30.00
  • $35.00
  • $40.00
  • $45.00
  • $50.00
  • $75.00
  • $100.00
$5.00
Cancel

Jars 2 items

Out of stock

Nutty PB Filling

We know how much you love the delectable peanut butter filling in Jessie's Nutty Cups, and now yo...
$10.00
Out of stock

Purely Nutty PB

This jar is pure peanuts. We take our freshly roasted peanuts, grind them up and put them straigh...
$9.00

Subscriptions 3 items

3-Month Subscription

Get your Nutty fix 3 months in a row! Each month you'll receive a box with a selection of several...
From  $75.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Random Assortment
  • Assortment - Milk Chocolate Preferred
  • Assortment - Dark Chocolate Preferred
$75.00
Cancel

6-Month Subscription

Get your Nutty fix 6 months in a row! Each month you'll receive a box with a selection of several...
From  $145.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Random Assortment
  • Assortment - Milk Chocolate Preferred
  • Assortment - Dark Chocolate Preferred
$145.00
Cancel

Ongoing Subscription

Get your Nutty fix automatically delivered every month!
Each month you'll receive a box with a s...
From  $17.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Random Assortment
  • Assortment - Milk Chocolate Preferred
  • Assortment - Dark Chocolate Preferred
$17.00
Cancel

Follow us

Your Cart

Total
$0.00 USD
Shipping & taxes calculated at checkout
Continue Shopping
Your cart is currently empty.
Click here to continue shopping.