Skip to main content
Search
🍫 All Nutty Cup Orders Are Shipped Monday - Thursday 🥜

Assortments 8 items

Create Your Own Assortment

Create your own assortment box with your favorite Nutty flavors!
*Orders made with the Dark Choc...
From  $22.00
+ ADD

Signature Nutty Assortment

Pre-assorted box with all of your favorite Nutty flavors! Handcrafted with Belgian chocolate and ...
From  $21.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Double Box - 23 Cups
  • Double Box - 30 Cups
$21.00
Cancel

Pre-Assorted Milk Chocolate

Our 3 best selling milk chocolate flavors in one box! Handcrafted with Belgian milk chocolate and...
From  $20.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Double Box - 23 Cups
  • Double Box - 30 Cups
$20.00
Cancel

Pre-Assorted Dark Chocolate

Our 3 best selling dark chocolate flavors in one box! Handcrafted with Belgian dark chocolate (60...
From  $20.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • Double Box - 23 Cups
  • Double Box - 30 Cups
$20.00
Cancel

Create Your Own 4-Pack

Choose up to 4 flavors and put together your own pack of 4 Nutty Cups!
*Orders made with the Dark...
From  $10.00
+ ADD

Nutty 2-Packs

Grab a 2-pack of your favorite Nutty Cup flavor! 
$5.00
+ ADD
  • Original Nutty Cups
  • Dark Sea Salt Cups
  • Nutty Cookies ‘n’ Cream Cups
  • Nutty Pretzel Cups (milk)
  • Nutty Pretzel Cups (dark)
  • Nutty PBJ Cups
  • Choco-Hazelnutty Cups
  • Nutty Almond Cups (milk)
  • Nutty Almond Cups (dark)
$5.00
Cancel

Nutty Uggos

We’re making Nutty Cups all the time… and sometimes they don’t come out perfectly and have turned...
From  $15.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
$15.00
Cancel

Customized Cups

Customize your Nutty Cups with a special message written right on top!
If you are hoping to simpl...
From  $28.00
+ ADD

Flavors 8 items

Original Nutty Cup

Where it all began... a true classic. Smooth dark, milk or white chocolate with Jessie's freshly ...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Milk Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
  • White Chocolate
$19.00
Cancel

Cup of the Month: Nutty Cookie Cup

Deliciously smooth Belgian milk chocolate surrounds a center of speculoos cookie butter mixed wit...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$20.00
Cancel

Dark Sea Salt Cup

Belgian dark chocolate surrounds Jessie’s freshly ground Peanut Butter filling, and we finish it ...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$19.00
Cancel

Nutty Cookies 'n' Cream Cup

Your favorite peanut butter cup but with a Cookies 'n' Cream twist! A Belgian chocolate shell (mi...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Milk Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
$19.00
Cancel

Nutty PBJ Cup

Creamy peanut butter and Maya's Jams handmade Triple Berry Jam (based on Jessie's original recipe...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$19.00
Cancel

Nutty Pretzel Cup

Peanut butter, Belgian milk or dark chocolate and pretzel. How could you possibly go wrong?
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
  • Milk Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
$19.00
Cancel

Nutty Almond Cup

Belgian milk or dark chocolate surrounds our creamy almond butter filling. Simply perfect!
 
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • 2-pack
  • Box of 15
  • Milk
  • Dark
$20.00
Cancel

Choco-Hazelnutty Cup

A combination of Nutella and our freshly ground peanut butter is surrounded by a Belgian chocolat...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
  • 2-pack
$19.00
Cancel

Gift Card 1 item

Nutty Gift Cards


Purchasing this digital gift card creates a unique code, which the lucky recipient can enter at ...
From  $5.00
+ ADD
  • $5.00
  • $10.00
  • $15.00
  • $20.00
  • $25.00
  • $30.00
  • $35.00
  • $40.00
  • $45.00
  • $50.00
  • $75.00
  • $100.00
$5.00
Cancel

Jars 2 items

Nutty PB Filling

We know how much you love the delectable peanut butter filling in Jessie's Nutty Cups, and now yo...
$10.00
+ ADD
$10.00
Cancel

Purely Nutty PB

This jar is pure peanuts. We take our freshly roasted peanuts, grind them up and put them straigh...
$9.00
+ ADD
$9.00
Cancel

Subscriptions 3 items

3-Month Subscription

Get your Nutty fix 3 months in a row! Each month you'll receive a box with a selection of several...
From  $75.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
$75.00
Cancel

6-Month Subscription

Get your Nutty fix 6 months in a row! Each month you'll receive a box with a selection of several...
From  $150.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
$150.00
Cancel

Ongoing Subscription

Get your Nutty fix automatically delivered every month!
Each month you'll receive a box with a s...
From  $18.00
+ ADD
  • Box of 8
  • Box of 15
$18.00
Cancel

Follow us

Your Cart

Total
$0.00 USD
Shipping & taxes calculated at checkout

During checkout please confirm your shipping address is accurate. Any changes made after shipment may incur additional fees.

Continue Shopping
Your cart is currently empty.
Click here to continue shopping.